Brasília (AFP) – Brazil’s government on Thursday joined Asian palm oil and coffee producers in welcoming a European Union decision to delay implementation of new anti-deforestation rules which had faced strong global pushback. Brazil, the United States, and other countries had criticized the law — which aims to prevent the import of products that drive deforestation — as being too complex, arguing it would particularly hurt small-scale producers. It had been due to take effect at the end of 2024, but the European Commission on Wednesday proposed delaying implementation for large companies until the end of 2025. Small businesses will have until June 2026 to comply.
Welcoming the postponement, Brazil’s agriculture ministry told AFP it was the fruit of “international dialogue, in which Brazil had a key role in underlining the concerns of our producers.” The ministry added that Brazil, home to about two-thirds of the Amazon rainforest, huge chunks of which have been felled for agriculture, remained “firmly committed to environmental preservation” and would seek to “ensure fair adaptation to the new European rules.” Asian commodity producers also expressed relief over the extension, but environmentalist groups voiced outrage.
Greenpeace declared EU chief Ursula von der Leyen “might as well have wielded the chainsaw herself” to the forests. The Brazilian Climate Observatory called the extension a “shameful step backwards,” which jeopardized the fight against deforestation as the country chokes from the smoke from thousands of fires caused mainly by clearing the Amazon. “Europe is deliberately renouncing an instrument that could help reduce the pressure on natural ecosystems and carbon dioxide emissions from deforestation,” it said in a statement.
The EU’s new law requires exporters of timber, cattle, cocoa, soy, palm oil, rubber, coffee — and items derived from those products — to certify their goods were not produced on land deforested after December 2020. The EU is the second-biggest market for the targeted products after China. Brazil in September asked the EU to postpone the legislation, complaining that the “punitive” rules increased production and export costs, especially for smallholders. Germany and other countries in Asia, Africa, and Latin America had also insisted that companies needed more time to prepare.
Divided opinions emerged as Nguyen Xuan Loi, head of Vietnamese coffee exporter An Thai Group, hailed the delay as a “positive move.” “In reality, Vietnam has been strictly managing deforestation issues,” he told AFP. “There are hardly any violations anymore.” There was also relief in some sectors in Indonesia, the world’s largest palm oil producer, a key driver of deforestation. “Our calls have been listened to,” said Eddy Martono, chairman of the country’s leading palm oil association. However, Indonesian environmental group WALHI expressed concern, stating it could “not imagine how much more land-clearing or deforestation the one-year delay could cause in West Kalimantan and other places like Papua.”
EU imports accounted for 16 percent of deforestation linked to global trade in 2017, according to WWF. When the law was adopted in 2023, it was hailed as a major breakthrough to protect nature and the climate. Under the law, firms importing the merchandise to the 27-nation EU will be responsible for tracking their supply chains to prove goods did not originate from deforested zones, relying on geolocation and satellite data. Exporting countries considered high-risk would have at least nine percent of products sent to the EU subjected to checks. The postponement of the law has yet to be approved by the European Parliament and member states.
© 2024 AFP
