London (AFP) – The date when Catholic cardinals will gather to select Pope Francis’s successor is not yet known. But bookmakers and crypto investors are already scrambling to guess who will be the next pontiff. Just days after Francis died on Monday, speculation on who would succeed him is already “one of the most popular betting markets in 2025,” FairPlay Sports Media, which provides sports betting insights, told AFP.
The next pope is among the 30 most active betting markets this year, overtaking even the hugely popular FA Cup, according to FairPlay. Italian cardinal Pietro Parolin, the Vatican’s chief diplomat who was Francis’s number two during much of his papacy, was leading several bookies’ lists in what experts say is a “multi-million dollar global market.” British bookmaker William Hill had Parolin out in the front with 9/4 odds—a safe bet.
At his heels was charismatic moderate Luis Antonio Tagle, a Filipino who could be the first Asian pope, at 3/1. Tussling between third and fourth place across lists was Matteo Zuppi, the archbishop of Bologna who served as the late pope’s special peace envoy for Ukraine. Oddschecker, a website which compares online bets, has a section dedicated to the “next pope,” which has been visited by over 100,000 users, according to FairPlay. While bookmakers have carved out early favourites, the outcome of the secretive papal conclave remains wildly unpredictable.
At least 15 days, and no more than 20 days after Pope Francis’s death, 135 cardinal electors are due to take part in a conclave to pick a successor, usually from among their ranks. While the Catholic Church frowns upon over-enthusiastic betters, gambling on the outcome has taken place for centuries. “What was once a pursuit confined largely to Renaissance Roman bankers and courtiers has evolved into a multi-million dollar global market accessible at the click of a button or a tap on a crypto wallet,” said Leighton Vaughan Williams, professor of economics and finance at Nottingham Business School.
The “papal betting market has grown substantially” from previous modern-day conclaves in 2005 and 2013, Vaughan Williams told AFP. However, “their accuracy in forecasting the secretive papal conclave remains inconsistent,” warned the researcher, who charted the outcomes of 500 years of conclave betting in a 2015 study. In 2013, Francis, born Jorge Mario Bergoglio, was not considered a favourite and was ranked as low as 40th on some bookmakers’ lists.
While Vatican experts and analysts weigh in on possible frontrunners, the cardinals who form the conclave are sworn to secrecy on pain of excommunication. “Without solid information to trade on…markets are largely reflecting speculation, media narratives, and existing biases,” said Vaughan Williams.
Interest has also surged this time following the 2024 release of the Oscar-winning film “Conclave,” which dramatises the pontiff’s selection process behind closed doors. One image widely circulated on X breaks down potential successors by their ideological beliefs, with users comparing them to characters in the fictional film. Some social media users have thrown their weight behind Tagle for his moderate views and tolerance towards LGBTQ individuals.
Another social media favourite is Cardinal Peter Turkson from Ghana, who could be in the running to become the first black pontiff. The speed with which betting activity took off this year “underscores an enduring cultural fascination with the papacy, amplified by media coverage and popular culture,” according to Vaughan Williams. Beyond bookmakers’ lists and seasoned betters, predictions have been thrown wide open with crypto-powered websites like Polymarket, where investors bet on future events.
The American website, which was popular during the US election won by Donald Trump, has already accepted over $5.5 million in bets on who will be the next pope. According to Vaughan Williams, platforms like Polymarket represent a “significant shift” by attracting more bets while navigating an “uncertain regulatory landscape.” Polymarket placed Cardinal Parolin at a leading 28 percent chance of becoming pontiff, and its comment section is rife with discussions on the competence of the favourites. “The next pope will be more religiously conservative but still open to progressive ideas on social issues,” mused one user. “Tagle for popedom,” wrote another.
© 2024 AFP
