Bergen (Norway) (AFP) – Companies are raring to explore the Arctic seabed off Norway, which could become the first country in Europe to allow deep-sea mining — much to the dismay of environmentalists. The industry has already suffered a false start. Norway’s parliament had voted massively in favour of deep-sea mining, experts had concluded there were significant resources to be extracted, and start-ups drawing on more than 50 years of offshore oil and gas experience were keen to begin operations. But then came a surprising turn of events.
In December, Norway’s government backpedalled on plans to award the first exploration licences in 2025, part of a compromise with a left-wing party in order to pass its budget through parliament. “It was of course a surprise and disappointment…that a small party could take over the budget negotiations and succeed in blocking something that parliament really wants,” said Anette Broch Mathisen Tvedt, managing director of the start-up Adepth. Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Store insisted it was simply a delay, not a change of heart. The first licences are now due to be awarded in 2026, in the Greenland Sea and the Norwegian Sea.
But the change of timeline had major repercussions for industry players, usually small companies made up of an entrepreneur and a handful of geologists or geophysicists. Loke Marine Minerals, which had hopes of becoming a world leader, declared bankruptcy last week. Its rival, Green Minerals, has had to cut costs by 80 percent. “We are as ready now as before to be awarded licences on the Norwegian continental shelf. We will be around for many years,” Green Minerals chief executive Oivind Dahl-Stamnes insisted.
Those in favour see deep-sea mining as a way of obtaining minerals and metals needed for the transition to green energy, and reducing dependence on China, which dominates the market by a big margin. “If we continue to have minerals supplied the way they are today, then it’s clear that the green transition will not be very green,” Mathisen Tvedt argued. Norway stands out in Europe, where countries like France, Germany, and Britain are reticent or even categorically opposed to deep-sea mining. Norway’s seabed is believed to hold “substantial” resources, including 38 million tonnes of copper and 45 million tonnes of zinc, as well as “significant” volumes of rare earth minerals, according to an official evaluation published in 2023.
– Clearing the way –
At a conference in early April in the Norwegian city of Bergen, AFP met industry players who said they hoped to extract their first minerals in the early 2030s or even by the end of this decade. Their plans have environmentalists up in arms, concerned about the impact their operations will have on marine ecosystems in the region, about which much is still unknown. In Bergen, delegates were met by Greenpeace leaflets with the plea “Don’t gamble with the ocean!” “Deep sea mining is a destructive industry that will destroy valuable and mostly unexplored ecosystems for minerals that we don’t need for the green transition,” argued Helene Bourges, global project leader at Greenpeace International.
Egil Tjaland, the secretary general of the Norwegian Forum for Marine Minerals, insisted Norway was well positioned to develop the sector. “It’s better to have a nation like Norway, with a good environmental record, start this and hopefully make a standard that can be used for other countries,” he said. “Because I think inevitably this will happen all over the world…It’s just a matter of time.” Environmental activists have lost the first round in the courts. An Oslo court in February rejected a legal challenge by the conservation organisation WWF, which accused the state of opening up Norway’s seabed to deep-sea mining without conducting sufficient impact studies. WWF has appealed against the ruling.
“All industrial activity has an impact. When it comes to minerals, the question is: ‘where is the impact smallest?'” argued Dahl-Stamnes of Green Minerals. “Is it smallest at a depth of 1,000 to 2,000 metres (3,300 to 6,600 feet) under the seabed, or in the traditional mining industry on land?” he asked rhetorically.
© 2024 AFP
