Paris (France) (AFP) – Oil and gas majors have high hopes for a quick reopening of the Strait of Hormuz, but they have few illusions about a return to normal for the Gulf energy industry after more than three months of blockage. Even if the deal between Iran and the United States to end the Mideast war holds, analysts say the old market certainties are gone for good — and the new risks will probably require costly adaptations.
“A credible reopening of the Strait of Hormuz would be one of the most important developments for the global economy at this juncture,” said Claudio Galimberti, chief economist at Rystad Energy. The shock of a near-doubling of oil prices since Iran effectively closed off the crucial waterway has fueled inflation that could persist for months, threatening growth around the globe. Its closure exposed the vulnerability of Gulf supply chains — and now the prospect of Iranian tolls on tanker and cargo traffic. Iran’s foreign ministry spokesman Esmaeil Baqaei has evoked maritime “service fees” on ships transiting the strait, which companies are likely to pass on to customers.
“We’re in a whole new era,” French expert Philippe Chalmin of the raw materials consulting group Cyclope said this month in presenting its annual market outlook, an industry reference. “Hormuz can be blocked — no one had imagined that,” he said, noting that a toll was likely. Energy firms appear to have resigned themselves to the fact, with TotalEnergies chief Patrick Pouyanne saying in April that “compensation” to Iran is preferable to having the strait stay closed.
Oil prices fell sharply after the deal was announced to around $80 a barrel, though that remains above the mid-$60s seen before the war. “We’re really waiting for the signature of a concrete agreement and tangible proof that the Strait of Hormuz is reopening,” said Blandine Ruty, secretary general of the French petroleum industry association Ufipem. She predicted that prices would fall further “if there indeed are signs of political stability”. However, if market sentiment has clearly improved, “sentiment is not the same as supply,” said Rystad’s Galimberti.
Retaliatory strikes by Iran have targeted oil and gas infrastructure in several Gulf countries seen helping the US attacks, taking many pumps and refineries offline. “It will take time for production to ramp back up, for logistics to normalize, and for the risk premium embedded in crude prices to dissipate,” he said. He also noted the United Arab Emirates’ decision during the war to quit OPEC, hindering the Saudi-dominated cartel’s ability to control oil prices. Chalmin at Cyclope meanwhile said “there are doubts that some wells will be able to quickly start flowing again — It’s not just a tap you turn back on”.
“This war showed the oil and gas industry that Hormuz risk is no longer just a geopolitical headline. It is a logistics, insurance, storage and balance sheet risk,” said Stephen Innes, an analyst at SPI Asset Management. He predicted the industry would shift from “just-in-time” to “just-in-case” logistics that mean “more storage, more flexible shipping, more diversified crude and LNG sourcing, and more planning around war-risk insurance”.
The UAE has already said it will fast-track construction of a new oil pipeline bypassing the Strait of Hormuz by reaching the port of Fujairah on the Gulf of Oman. But that marginally eases shipping risks only for crude oil, given the overwhelming importance of tanker shipments — liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports require ships for reaching key Asian and European markets. “For refined products and LNG, if the Strait of Hormuz is blocked, you’re blocked 100 percent,” said Francis Perrin of the French Institute for International and Strategic Affairs (IRIS), a contributor to Cyclope’s annual report.
Even if producers build more “resilience” into their operations, it will be reflected in their costs. “The industry should rethink storage, pipelines, production diversity and transit routes, but only within realistic limits,” Innes said. “You can build buffers, but you cannot build another Hormuz overnight.”
© 2024 AFP
