Washington (United States) (AFP) – A wave of American wealth created by artificial intelligence companies could produce some of the largest charitable sums since the era of Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller, raising questions about where the money goes. Anthropic, the maker of the Claude chatbot, has said it would commit 5 percent of its shares to a new Anthropic Public Benefit Fund, a stake that could be worth around $100 billion if the company reaches the $2 trillion valuation investors are eyeing for a stock market debut expected as early as November. Combined with pledges by its seven co-founders to give away 80 percent of their equity and a program matching employees’ donations, Anthropic says roughly a fifth of its shares will be dedicated to public-benefit purposes.
“This might be one of the biggest stories in corporate philanthropy ever,” said Michael Moody, a professor of philanthropic studies at Indiana University’s Lilly Family School of Philanthropy. The OpenAI Foundation, the nonprofit that controls ChatGPT maker OpenAI, holds a 26 percent stake in the company that was valued at about $130 billion when it was restructured a year ago, more than the endowment of the Gates Foundation. Nan Ransohoff of payments firm Stripe has described the moment as a “third wave” of American philanthropy, after the industrial fortunes of the late 19th century and the internet billionaires of recent decades.
Carnegie argued in his 1889 essay “The Gospel of Wealth” that “the man who dies thus rich dies disgraced,” and by his death had given away the bulk of his fortune, about $350 million. Carnegie transferred what remained into a trust, which has continued to make grants for more than a century. Rockefeller’s money built universities and funded medical research and public health campaigns around the world. Railroad magnate Cornelius Vanderbilt gave comparatively little, apart from the $1 million that founded the university bearing his name.
Anthropic is setting up its fund as a limited liability company that it wholly owns, rather than as a nonprofit foundation, which must pay out a minimum share of its assets each year and file public tax returns. “The trade-off is that decision-making stays with the company and transparency is voluntary,” said Sarah Wolfolds, who studies nonprofit organizations at Cornell University’s SC Johnson College of Business. Anthropic has said the fund’s equity will not be used for lobbying or political giving and that it will report on its activities.
Many Anthropic founders and staff have close ties to effective altruism, a movement that favors causes such as AI safety and global health because of their measurable impact. “Nonprofits tend to reorient their programs toward where the money is,” Wolfolds said, warning that other causes can become neglected. Moody said the philanthropic world would be “looking closely at which causes they support,” including whether research funding is limited to AI. Laura McGarry, of fundraising consultancy Graham-Pelton, said the charities best placed to benefit are those that already have relationships with the newly wealthy. “It’s really about values alignment,” she said, adding that charities that court the newly rich only after their big payday risk looking transactional. Effective altruism has shaped some donors’ giving but has not “dramatically upset the apple cart,” she said.
Anthropic has said the fund could make payments directly to groups affected by AI’s impact on jobs, without giving details. Research on cash transfers is encouraging, Wolfolds said, but “the harder challenge may be identifying who has been affected by AI.” Such payments should complement, not replace, unemployment insurance and retraining programs, she said.
Elon Musk, the world’s richest person, whose SpaceX owns rival AI developer xAI, criticized Anthropic’s approach. “I recommend giving the shares directly to the public,” he wrote on X. As an alternative, Musk pledged one of his SpaceX shares to every American child next year, a gift worth about $10.5 billion. US President Donald Trump praised the move as fitting the philosophy behind his “Trump Accounts,” government-backed investment accounts for children born between 2025 and 2028. Billionaires Michael and Susan Dell have pledged billions to the program.
© 2024 AFP
